Film board

Critics vs crowd: war films of all time

When

Genre

Min votes

Films with both scores

183

10K+ votes each

Within 5 points

28%

of the 183 most voted

Metascore against IMDb ratingIMDb x 10 higherMetascore higher

Metascore well above the IMDb rating

Critics loved it, the crowd didn't

Critics vs crowd: war films of all time: Critics loved it, the crowd didn't
#
1	Timbuktu	2014	92	71	21
2	The Hurt Locker	2008	95	75	20
3	The Zone of Interest	2023	92	73	19
4	Coriolanus	2011	79	61	18
5	Army of Shadows	1969	99	81	18
6	Beau Travail	1999	91	73	18
7	Da 5 Bloods	2020	82	65	17
8	Son of Saul	2015	91	74	17
9	Quo Vadis, Aida?	2020	97	80	17
10	Pan's Labyrinth	2006	98	82	16
11	Shadow in the Cloud	2020	66	50	16
12	Lebanon	2009	85	69	16
13	Casablanca	1942	100	85	15
14	Gone with the Wind	1939	97	82	15
15	Ran	1985	97	82	15
16	The Battle of Algiers	1966	96	81	15
17	Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb	1964	97	83	14
18	The Man Who Would Be King	1975	91	77	14
19	Bloody Sunday	2002	90	76	14
20	Virunga	2014	95	81	14
21	They Were Expendable	1945	86	72	14
22	Love and Death	1975	89	76	13
23	Richard III	1995	86	73	13
24	Platoon	1986	92	80	12
25	The English Patient	1996	86	74	12

IMDb rating well above the Metascore

Critics vs crowd: war films of all time: The crowd loved it, critics didn't
#
1	My Way	2011	30	76	46
2	Little Boy	2015	30	73	43
3	Johnny Got His Gun	1971	41	78	37
4	Man Down	2015	28	60	32
5	Legends of the Fall	1994	45	75	30
6	Love and Honor	2013	28	57	29
7	Kelly's Heroes	1970	50	76	26
8	Rock the Kasbah	2015	29	55	26
9	Air America	1990	33	58	25
10	Jakob the Liar	1999	40	65	25
11	Head in the Clouds	2004	40	65	25
12	5 Days of War	2011	31	56	25
13	Miracle at St. Anna	2008	37	61	24
14	Judgment at Nuremberg	1961	60	83	23
15	1941	1979	34	57	23
16	Enemy at the Gates	2001	53	75	22
17	The Boy in the Striped Pajamas	2008	55	77	22
18	The Book Thief	2013	53	75	22
19	Red Dawn	2012	31	53	22
20	The Round Up	2010	49	71	22
21	Jojo Rabbit	2019	58	79	21
22	The Aftermath	2019	43	64	21
23	The Children of Huang Shi	2008	49	70	21
24	Hyena Road	2015	44	65	21
25	Dear John	2010	43	63	20