Critics vs crowd: romance films of all time | Reelmigo

Metascore well above the IMDb rating

Critics loved it, the crowd didn't

Critics vs crowd: romance films of all time: Critics loved it, the crowd didn't
#
1	Journey to Italy	1954	100	72	28
2	Love & Friendship	2016	87	63	24
3	45 Years	2015	94	71	23
4	All We Imagine as Light	2024	93	70	23
5	Babygirl	2024	79	57	22
6	The Duke of Burgundy	2014	87	65	22
7	Carol	2015	94	73	21
8	Jules and Jim	1962	97	76	21
9	Three Colors: Red	1994	100	80	20
10	Masculine Feminine	1966	93	73	20
11	The Deep Blue Sea	2011	82	62	20
12	Sideways	2004	94	75	19
13	Licorice Pizza	2021	90	71	19
14	Rachel Getting Married	2008	85	66	19
15	The Diary of a Teenage Girl	2015	87	68	19
16	Days of Being Wild	1990	93	74	19
17	The Lady Eve	1941	96	77	19
18	The Love Witch	2016	82	63	19
19	The Band Wagon	1953	93	74	19
20	Vertigo	1958	100	82	18
21	My Fair Lady	1964	95	77	18
22	Black Bag	2025	85	67	18
23	The Age of Innocence	1993	90	72	18
24	The Crying Game	1992	90	72	18
25	The Adventures of Robin Hood	1938	97	79	18

IMDb rating well above the Metascore

The crowd loved it, critics didn't

Critics vs crowd: romance films of all time: The crowd loved it, critics didn't
#
1	The Vanishing of Sidney Hall	2017	18	68	50
2	Cocktail	1988	12	60	48
3	The Tiger and the Snow	2005	22	70	48
4	Some Kind of Beautiful	2014	11	57	46
5	Collateral Beauty	2016	23	68	45
6	Somewhere in Time	1980	29	72	43
7	Miss March	2009	7	50	43
8	The Majestic	2001	27	69	42
9	The Accidental Husband	2008	14	56	42
10	Slackers	2002	12	53	41
11	Sweet November	2001	27	67	40
12	The Loft	2014	24	63	39
13	The Choice	2016	26	65	39
14	Mother's Day	2016	18	57	39
15	London	2005	24	63	39
16	A Walk to Remember	2002	35	73	38
17	Van Wilder	2002	26	64	38
18	The Best of Me	2014	29	67	38
19	Night Train to Lisbon	2013	30	68	38
20	Good Luck Chuck	2007	19	56	37
21	The Longest Ride	2015	33	70	37
22	Purple Hearts	2022	30	67	37
23	Before We Go	2014	31	68	37
24	Saving Silverman	2001	22	59	37
25	After We Collided	2020	14	51	37

Critics vs crowd: romance films of all time | Reelmigo