Head to headPhyllis Logan against Laura Carmichael Both careers by TMDB ratingPhyllis LoganLaura Carmichael
Tale of the tape as an actor
Phyllis Logan vs Laura Carmichael
Laura Carmichael averages 6.69 across 7 rated films as an actor, ahead of Phyllis Logan at 6.59.
- 22 (16 rated)
- Films acted
- 7
- 6.59
- Average
- 6.69▶
- 6.65
- Weighted
- 6.70▶
- ◀Secrets & Lies 7.6
- Best film
- Downton Abbey: A New Era 7.2
- 6.87, 1995 to 2019
- Peak five
- 6.90, 2016 to 2025▶
- 2 films
- Longest 7+ run
- 3 films▶
- ◀6.87 (+0.28)
- Current form
- 6.90 (+0.21)
- ◀6.98K
- TMDB votes
- 6.31K
- 1983 to 2025
- Career
- 2011 to 2025
- None
- Oscars
- None
- $437M
- Box office
- $491M▶
Rows won
3 to 5
Laura Carmichael ahead
Films together
3
averaging 7.14
Dot size shows audience votes. Films below the source vote floor sit on the baseline.
 Downton Abbey | 2019 | 7.2 | as Mrs Hughes | as Edith Crawley |
 Downton Abbey: A New Era | 2022 | 7.2 | as Mrs Hughes | as Edith Crawley |
 Downton Abbey: The Grand Finale | 2025 | 7.1 | as Elsie Hughes | as Lady Edith |