Head to headPeter MacNeill against Bill MacDonald Both careers by TMDB ratingPeter MacNeillBill MacDonald
Tale of the tape as an actor
Peter MacNeill vs Bill MacDonald
Peter MacNeill averages 6.25 across 28 rated films as an actor, ahead of Bill MacDonald at 5.85.
- 36 (28 rated)
- Films acted
- 15 (11 rated)
- ◀6.25
- Average
- 5.85
- ◀6.45
- Weighted
- 6.05
- ◀Life in a Year 8.2
- Best film
- A History of Violence 7.2
- ◀6.99, 2019 to 2025
- Peak five
- 6.09, 2000 to 2021
- ◀3 films
- Longest 7+ run
- None
- ◀6.99 (+0.74)
- Current form
- 5.94 (+0.09)
- ◀25.9K
- TMDB votes
- 10.1K
- 1976 to 2025
- Career
- 1989 to 2024
- None
- Oscars
- None
- ◀$489M
- Box office
- $267M
Rows won
8 to 0
Peter MacNeill ahead
Films together
4
averaging 6.30
Dot size shows audience votes. Films below the source vote floor sit on the baseline.
 Who Is Cletis Tout? | 2001 | 5.9 | as Detective Tripp | as Detective Delaney |
 A History of Violence | 2005 | 7.2 | as Sheriff Sam Carney | as Frank Mulligan |
 The Marsh | 2006 | 5.2 | as Philip Manville | as Dr. Wells |
 Nightmare Alley | 2021 | 6.9 | as Judge Kimball | as Stanton’s Dad |