Head to headHoagy Carmichael against Syd Saylor Both careers by TMDB ratingHoagy CarmichaelSyd Saylor
Tale of the tape as an actor
Hoagy Carmichael vs Syd Saylor
Hoagy Carmichael averages 6.72 across 7 rated films as an actor, ahead of Syd Saylor at 6.31.
- 10 (7 rated)
- Films acted
- 78 (32 rated)
- ◀6.72
- Average
- 6.31
- ◀6.85
- Weighted
- 6.38
- ◀The Best Years of Our Lives 7.7
- Best film
- Scarlet Street 7.6
- 6.93, 1937 to 1946
- Peak five
- 7.24, 1942 to 1945▶
- None
- Longest 7+ run
- 3 films▶
- ◀6.59 (−0.13)
- Current form
- 5.53 (−0.77)
- 1.73K
- TMDB votes
- 3.66K▶
- 1937 to 1955
- Career
- 1930 to 1963
- ◀1 win, 2 noms
- Oscars
- None
- $36.8M
- Box office
- $73.5M▶
Rows won
5 to 4
Hoagy Carmichael ahead
Films together
3
averaging 6.35
Dot size shows audience votes. Films below the source vote floor sit on the baseline.
 Topper | 1937 | 6.7 | as Hoagy - Piano Player (uncredited) | as Car Salesman (uncredited) |
 The Las Vegas Story | 1952 | 6.0 | as Happy | as Matty (uncredited) |
 Belles on Their Toes | 1952 | · | as Tom Bracken | as Cab Driver (uncredited) |